Question of the Week · Week of October 29, 2026

Commercial roof repair vs replace — how to decide

Replace, or at least tear off, when a moisture survey finds moisture in 25% or more of the roof area, when the roof already has two or more roof coverings, or when the roof is past its service life. Below those lines, cut out and replace the wet areas, fix leaks and drainage, then repair, recover or coat. The 25% figure is GAF’s liquid-applied roofing guidance; the two-coverings limit is the International Building Code’s roof recover rule. On Episode 011, Keith Bilous puts the field version plainly: there has to be life left in the roof to coat it.

Question of the Week for the week of October 29, 2026. Cited from Episode 011, Episode 001, Episode 002, and Episode 010. Have a question for the show? Contact Roofing Authority Network.

Later write-up that supports this page: Episode 013 (John Kiesel says TPO failed early, some manufacturers no longer exist because of it, and testing does not replace field application, time and climate).

Decision rules you can check

Each rule below links to the public source that states it. These are code and manufacturer rules, not Tie-In opinions. Your local code adoption and your manufacturer’s current warranty terms decide the final call.

  1. Wet area of 25% or more: plan a tear-off. GAF’s Liquid-Applied Roofing Manual says that if a moisture survey shows 25% or more of the roof area contains moisture, a complete tear-off may be considered, and that a tear-off is required at that level for its Liquid-Applied NDL Diamond Pledge guarantee. All wet insulation must be removed and replaced before coating. GAF Liquid-Applied Roofing Manual · GAF: Roof coating vs. commercial replacement
  2. Two or more existing roof coverings: no recover. IBC Section 1511.3.1.1 (2018 edition) says a roof recover is not permitted where the existing roof has two or more applications of any roof covering, or where it is water soaked or deteriorated to the point that it is not an adequate base. Replacement under the code means removing all layers down to the deck. IBC 2018 §1511.3.1.1 as adopted in Okla. Admin. Code 784:20-2-20
  3. Verify the survey with core cuts. For its Diamond Pledge guarantee, GAF requires at least three core cuts for the first 100 squares and one per additional 100 squares. IIBEC says every non-destructive moisture survey method (infrared, nuclear, impedance) needs roof cores to confirm it. GAF Liquid-Applied Roofing Manual · IIBEC Technical Advisory 016-2018
  4. Past its service life: replace. GAF says a coating cannot add life back to a roof that is already beyond its service life, and that ponding that cannot be resolved and leaks that repairs cannot stop are red flags for coating. GAF: Roof coating vs. commercial replacement

No public code or manufacturer source we could verify sets a roof age in years, or a repair-spend percentage of replacement cost, that forces a replacement. This page does not publish one.

Like, if you're gonna be making million-dollar decisions, I think it still makes sense to do a core cut, um, at, especially at this stage.

Bilal Sher · Episode 012 · 00:46:01. Field Edition · Play 00:46:01

There has to be life left to coat it

On Episode 011, Keith Bilous asks Steve Reiss where he draws the line with owners. The transcript keeps the question and the answer in one chunk labeled Keith Bilous.

The, the direct answer is this: there has to be life left in the roof in order to restore it/coat it, because a lot of coatings, they're not, it's not necessarily a waterproofing system.

Keith Bilous · Episode 011 · 00:10:29. Field Edition · Play 00:10:29

Restore or replace

Keith Bilous · Episode 011 · 00:10:11. Read the Field Edition · Open this minute

A dry ceiling is not the test

On Episode 002, Steve tells owners who think they are fine that the roof is probably already leaking.

No, I think I'm good. My roof isn't leaking right now." Well, I promise you it probably is. You just don't know it yet.

Steve Reiss · Episode 002 · 18:00. Field Edition · Play 18:00

Holly Fuller of CBRE says the first meeting should be a walk, not a one-line bid. She and Steve both treat a vague scope as the thing that makes two proposals impossible to compare. That walk is also how you see whether you are pricing a repair or a replacement.

taking that time out of your schedule to, like, walk it together, right? Be there in person,

Holly Fuller · Episode 002 · 38:00. Field Edition · Play 38:00 · What property managers should ask first

Buying time is a capital decision

On Episode 001, Keith says owners are calling contractors to ask how to buy some time. A produced desk segment says they are calling for a coating quote and a few more years instead of a tear-off. John, president of Division 7 Roofing as Keith addresses him on Episode 004, answers from the field.

we're seeing a lot of, you know, attempts to prolong the life of a roof, uh, uh, avoiding that capital expenditure, which is the largest capital expenditure a, a building owner will face when it comes to maintaining their property is the roof.

John Kiesel · Episode 001 · 14:00. Field Edition · Play 14:00

He does not give a rule for how many years of life make a coating honest. He says pushing the replacement out is the owner’s motivation because the roof is the largest capital spend on the property.

One repair conversation, not a price list

Reed Dietz says Roof Revivers was started as a repair-only business, and that he and Joey Sayer — the transcript spelling; the Service Side page says Joey Sayre — went out selling repairs. He describes how he puts the choice to an owner on a single roof. The dollar figure is his example from that conversation. It is not a commercial rate, and nobody on these episodes stated a cost per square foot. For repair work, use roofrevivers.com rather than a price invented here.

They had sold that, and they started Roof Revivers, uh, in 2012. And they were going to nationally franchise the business for, like, a roof repair only business.

Reed Dietz · Episode 011 · 00:21:29. Field Edition · Play 00:21:29 · Roof Revivers

Listen, we can do this repair. It's gonna be $2,300, but your roof is, like, a few years away from needing to be replaced, so do you wanna reinvest that money in another three years, or do you just wanna, like, total the roof out now and replace it?

Reed Dietz · Episode 011 · 00:25:04. Field Edition · Play 00:25:04

Some roofs should not be repaired

On Episode 010, John says Division 7 used to get fired for failing to stop leaks on roofs that were already decades past replacement. He now refuses the call.

Your roof should've been replaced 20 years ago, and unfortunately we're not going to go out there and try to fix it for you because you're gonna call in and complain. No thank you.

John Kiesel · Episode 010 · 01:04:22. Field Edition · Play 01:04:22

Questions this record can answer

What share of wet insulation means replace instead of coat?

GAF’s Liquid-Applied Roofing Manual says that if a moisture survey shows 25% or more of the roof area contains moisture, a complete tear-off may be considered, and GAF requires one at that level for its Diamond Pledge guarantee. Below that, the wet areas must be removed and replaced before coating. Source.

Can a new roof go over the existing one?

Under IBC Section 1511.3.1.1 (2018), a recover is not permitted where the existing roof has two or more applications of roof covering or is water soaked or deteriorated. Check your local code adoption. Source.

Do I need core cuts if I already have a scan?

Yes. IIBEC says infrared, nuclear and impedance moisture surveys all need roof cores to confirm the findings. On Episode 012, Bilal Sher says a core cut still makes sense before a million-dollar decision. Source.

How do these episodes say to choose repair or replacement?

Keith Bilous says the direct answer is that there has to be life left in the roof to restore or coat it, because many coatings are not a waterproofing system. He asks Steve Reiss where he draws that line. Holly Fuller says walk the roof together before you bid. John Kiesel says he will not try to fix a roof that should have been replaced 20 years ago.

If the ceiling is dry, can I keep repairing?

Steve Reiss says owners tell him the roof is fine because it is not leaking right now. His reply is that it probably is leaking and they do not know it yet.

When is a repair the wrong job?

John Kiesel says Division 7 used to get fired for failing to stop leaks on roofs that should have been replaced 20 years earlier. He now refuses those calls before the crew goes out.

Did anyone publish a price for that decision?

Reed Dietz describes one conversation in which he told an owner a repair would be $2,300 and the roof was a few years from replacement. That is one job he described. It is not a commercial price list, and no speaker gave a cost per square foot. See commercial roof cost per square foot.

Have a question for the show? Contact Roofing Authority Network.