Issue 013September 28, 20261:24:03 replay

The membrane issue

What Comes After TPO?

Keith asks what comes after TPO and what it would take to trust it. Dr. Dhaval Gajjar explains how roofing went from 45 minutes of Clemson’s construction management curriculum to four courses. John Kiesel says the next membrane needs a compelling reason and a manufacturer standing behind it.

What Comes After TPO? Play issue 013 Field Edition · Episode 013

The episode

What this hour actually covers.

Keith opens the special Monday episode by saying TPO did not win because it was poetry; it won because it was fast, light and weldable. John says everything in roofing is an experiment, except maybe thatch. On the desk, he welcomes federal training grants he has lobbied for on the industry’s DC days, says speed gets a contractor in the door before quality is proven, and dismisses a paid article about coating a data center roof as coating propaganda. He says the system that wins in the future will accommodate robotic installation.

Dr. Dhaval Gajjar of Clemson joins. He says he came into roofing through a graduate project at Arizona State in 2009, came to Clemson in 2018, and found roofing had 45 minutes in the four-year construction management curriculum. He describes the Center for Roofing Innovation and Leadership, which he says is powered by the Roofing Alliance; four roofing courses worth 12 credits; more than 450 Clemson students since spring 2019; 15 other institutions using the curriculum; and more than 900 professionals through the certificate courses. John says Division 7 has put about eight staff through the certificate. Dhaval also talks about defining scope, mapping career paths, and a planned modular classroom and research space.

After the interview, Above the Line honors Heidi Ellsworth, whom John calls the megaphone of the industry. John says the Clemson work gives him hope, warns that you do not clean an old membrane with gasoline, and answers Hector’s question about what it would take to put his name on the membrane that comes after TPO. He says TPO failed early and took whole manufacturers with it, and that the ASTM standards say testing does not replace field application, time and climate. Keith closes on an August 1998 Interface Magazine article on TPO in the United States.

Editorial synthesis on this page is labeled by staying inside what the speakers and produced segments say. Direct quotations below are sliced from the transcript and link to that minute on YouTube.

Transcript-verified route

One clean path through the replay.

Each chapter is a minute where the transcript changes subject. The link opens the official replay at that minute.

  1. 011:24OpenWhat comes after TPO. Keith sets the question: what comes after TPO, and what it would take to trust it.Play
  2. 022:12Why TPO wonFast, light, weldable. Keith says TPO won the last 20 years of commercial roofs on speed, weight and welding, not poetry.Play
  3. 034:21ExperimentsEverything but thatch. John says every roofing system is an experiment, and that TPO had rocky roads and bad history on the way through R&D.Play
  4. 045:58DeskGrant money for the trades. After a produced line on $65 million in community college training grants, John says roofing asks for trade funding every year on its DC days.Play
  5. 058:11ServiceSpeedy, then speedy and good. John says speed gets a contractor in the door, quality is proven over time, and the move from one to the other is where Division 7 lives.Play
  6. 0611:26CoatingsNot the savior to PVC. John calls a paid article on coating a data center roof coating propaganda. He says coatings have their applications but are not the savior to PVC.Play
  7. 0719:40The guestForty-five minutes of roofing. Dr. Dhaval Gajjar says he came into roofing through a dissertation project in 2009, and that when he reached Clemson in 2018, roofing had 45 minutes in the construction management curriculum.Play
  8. 0823:08The centerPowered by the Roofing Alliance. Dhaval describes the Center for Roofing Innovation and Leadership, formed about two years ago, and says other trades now want what roofing built with Clemson.Play
  9. 0934:44The numbersFour courses, 15 institutions. Dhaval says more than 450 Clemson students have taken roofing courses since spring 2019, and that 15 other institutions use the curriculum.Play
  10. 1037:53CertificatesNine hundred professionals. John says Division 7 put about eight staff through Clemson’s certificate. Dhaval says over 900 professionals have taken the four eight-hour courses.Play
  11. 1155:30A stake in the groundA physical center. Dhaval says a modular classroom and research space is being planned, with hands-on deck exercises for high school students, professionals and college students.Play
  12. 121:03:11Above the lineHeidi Ellsworth. John introduces Heidi Ellsworth of Roofing Coffee Shop, RT3 and Women in Roofing as the megaphone of the industry.Play
  13. 131:12:49The Tie-InPutting a name on the next membrane. Asked what it would take to put his name on the membrane after TPO, John lists labor, time, defects and sustainability, then asks who will stand behind it with him.Play
  14. 141:16:01TestingLab tests and field time. John says the ASTM standards make clear that testing does not replace field application, time and climate.Play
  15. 151:17:06HistoryTPO in 1998. Keith reads from an August 1998 Interface Magazine article on TPO in the United States and notes that ASTM’s first TPO material spec followed five years later.Play

What a contractor can use.

A new membrane needs a reason and a backer.John says he would put his name on the next membrane only for a compelling reason: saved labor, saved time, fewer installation defects, or better sustainability. He would also need to know who stands behind it with him.
Lab tests are not field history.John says the ASTM standards make clear that testing does not replace field application, time and climate. He says TPO failed early, and some manufacturers no longer exist because of it.
Get the cleaning and repair guidance before you warranty.John says cleaning and re-welding guidance comes from the manufacturer, and that for a 15-year-old membrane the process sometimes has not been worked out yet.
Define the scope, then say what you will do.Dhaval says a tight scope means fewer surprises, because the work is all about risk. His rule is to do what you say and say what you’re gonna do.
Office staff can learn roofing too.John says Division 7 put about eight staff through Clemson’s certificate program. Dhaval says the four eight-hour courses need no prerequisites and no trip to Clemson.

Only what this episode establishes.

Guest, Clemson University

Dr. Dhaval Gajjar

The YouTube description identifies Dr. Dhaval Gajjar as Director of Clemson’s Center for Roofing Innovation and Leadership. On the episode he says he came into roofing through a professor’s roofing project during graduate school at Arizona State University in 2009. He says he worked in the industry for about five years and came to Clemson’s construction management program in 2018.

He says his undergraduate degree is in biochemistry and that he once wanted to be a surgeon. He tells viewers they can find him on the Clemson website.

Host, Division 7

John Kiesel

John co-hosts for Division 7. He says the industry goes to Washington every year for its DC days to lobby for trade funding, and that Division 7 has put about eight staff through Clemson’s certificate. He also says Division 7 has people in the office with master’s degrees in geology and business management.

Host

Keith Bilous

Keith hosts the special Monday episode, frames the question of what comes after TPO, and reads the history segment and Division 7 Roofing messages.

Verbatim

Lines from the transcript.

Whitespace is collapsed. A leading ellipsis means the line starts inside a longer turn. The full speaker-labelled transcript is published as JSON.

00:04:21

…Uh, everything's an experiment except for maybe thatch.
John Kiesel00:04:21 · transcriptPlay 00:04:21

00:08:11

…So, you know, there is a transition along the way from being speedy to being speedy and good, and that's where we live.
John Kiesel00:08:11 · transcriptPlay 00:08:11

00:19:40

…So students have 45 minutes worth of education in the entire four-year construction management program, and I'm like, "That is not acceptable," right?
Dhaval Gajjar00:19:40 · transcriptPlay 00:19:40

00:30:59

…So there's a simple saying I've used, uh, do what you say and say what you're gonna do, right?
Dhaval Gajjar00:30:59 · transcriptPlay 00:30:59

01:13:43

…Whole entire, uh, manufacturers are no longer in existence because it failed.
John Kiesel01:13:43 · transcriptPlay 01:13:43

01:16:01

…they're very clear about the testing does not replace field application and time and climate.
John Kiesel01:16:01 · transcriptPlay 01:16:01

Answers from this episode.

What would it take for a contractor to trust a membrane after TPO?

John Kiesel says it would take a compelling reason: saving labor or time, eliminating installation defects, helping sustainability, or doing something today’s materials don’t. He says he would also need to know who stands behind it with him, starting with the people who made it.

Did TPO have problems when it was new?

John says there were a lot of TPO failures when it was first made and rolled out, and that whole manufacturers no longer exist because of it. In the history segment, Keith reads that an August 1998 Interface Magazine article still called TPO a new generation of roofing membrane, and that ASTM published its first TPO material spec five years later.

Do ASTM tests prove a new roof membrane will last?

John says the ASTM standards are very clear that testing does not replace field application, time and climate. He says some materials have failed in major ways years into an installation.

What roofing education does Clemson offer?

Dr. Dhaval Gajjar says Clemson has four roofing courses that count for 12 credits toward a construction management degree. He says more than 450 Clemson students have taken them since spring 2019, and 15 other institutions use the curriculum. A certificate program for working professionals has four eight-hour courses with no prerequisites, and he says more than 900 professionals have completed it.

Is a coating a replacement for a PVC roof on a data center?

Responding to a paid article about one data center roof, John Kiesel says one roof with an issue doesn’t make coating the best application and doesn’t erode PVC’s quality or performance. He says coating has its applications, but he wouldn’t rush to call it the savior to PVC.

Episode 013 sources and the YouTube gap

Transcript: /data/transcripts/013.json. Title in the file: What Comes After TPO?.

Replay: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bNBPUJu4mQc. Runtime kept from the existing episode page: 1:24:03.

YouTube title retrieved by oEmbed: What Comes After TPO? | Dr. Dhaval Gajjar, Clemson | The Tie-In #013

YouTube auto-captions and the full video description could not be retrieved from this environment. yt-dlp and the transcript API were blocked by YouTube’s bot check on the cloud address used to fetch them. Official oEmbed titles were retrieved on 28 October 2026 where noted. Chapter order, quotations and guest facts on this page come from the speaker-labelled transcript in the repository. Produced desk lines (B-Roll, Commercial, and the named cast readers) are labeled as show segments. Statistics spoken inside those segments are attributed to the speaker, not republished as independent findings. The transcript index records published_at 2026-09-28. This page keeps the date already published on the episode, September 28, 2026. The oEmbed title for this episode was retrieved on 30 October 2026. This was a special Monday episode. YouTube records the live broadcast as starting at 10:03 AM Eastern on 28 September 2026. The transcript spells the guest's name several ways, including Duvall, Deval and Dabal. This page uses Dr. Dhaval Gajjar, as in the YouTube title. It often spells the co-host Jon. This page uses John Kiesel. The YouTube description promises self-healing and next-generation membranes, but the interview is mostly about education and careers. This page follows the transcript. Technical membrane claims made in produced segments, including the self-healing segment, are attributed to those segments and are not presented as independent findings.