Question of the Week · Week of November 12, 2026

TPO vs EPDM vs PVC: which should I choose?

John Kiesel does not pick one membrane for every roof. On Episode 013 he says TPO, PVC, and EPDM all arrived as experiments after hot tar. He says EPDM seams were glued and failed, TPO heat-welds the seam, and TPO is white, reflective, and still relatively new. He places TPO between EPDM and PVC, and he says he believes PVC is the more premium assembly. No guest on that episode stated a price or a service life in years for any of the three.

Question of the Week for the week of November 12, 2026. Cited from Episode 013. The only year count on that episode for a roof system is coal tar pitch, on how long a commercial roof lasts. Have a question for the show? Contact Roofing Authority Network.

All three arrived as experiments

Keith puts a clip of TPO on the roof and asks whether TPO was once an experiment. John answers for all three single-plies, and he puts them after hot tar.

Yeah, TPO was an experiment. PVC was an experiment. EPDM, experimental. You know, these things were brought into the industry after the, you know, the, what is it? The hot tar roofs.

John Kiesel · Episode 013 · 00:04:03. Field Edition · Play 00:04:03

the concept of TPO being a product that was new, it certainly had, you know, some rocky roads and some bad history behind it, but, you know, I think we're heading through the R&D phase.

John Kiesel · Episode 013 · 00:04:21. Field Edition · Play 00:04:21

Early TPO failures took manufacturers with them

Later in the same episode, Keith asks what comes after TPO. John says new membranes are usually proven in Europe before they arrive here, and that TPO did not get that sequence. The repair-or-replace page already cites this minute for the failures.

if we make them here, like TPO, it was supposed to be deployed in Europe to get its, um, use cases under control. Oh, really? And so, you know, there was a lot of failures in TPO when it was first built, made, rolled out. Whole entire, uh, manufacturers are no longer in existence because it failed.

John Kiesel · Episode 013 · 01:13:43. Field Edition · Play 01:13:43 · Repair or replace

The seam is the difference he names

Asked to reach back into the history, John defines the letters, then the seam. EPDM is the rubber roof with glued seams. TPO’s heat-welded seam is what he says solved that failure and made TPO popular. He also says it is white and reflective.

Thermoplastic olefin is TPO.

John Kiesel · Episode 013 · 01:18:25. Field Edition · Play 01:18:25

there's a EPDM roof, a rubber roof. Mm-hmm. It has glued seams that hold it together. TPO comes out and says, "Hey, we're gonna weld or heat-weld the seam technology together," because the EPDM seams were failing because of the glue, so it was an instant solving a seam problem to why it became so wildly popular.

John Kiesel · Episode 013 · 01:18:34. Field Edition · Play 01:18:34

Glue seam, then a weld

John Kiesel · Episode 013 · 01:18:34. Read the Field Edition · Open this minute

Where he puts PVC

He walks the sequence from EPDM replacing built-up roofs, then into TPO. PVC is the assembly he puts above TPO, and he gives time in existence as one reason. He still calls TPO relatively new. He does not name a building type, a climate, or a price that forces the choice.

EPDM was, was kind of built ar- around in the '60, '70- Okay.

John Kiesel · Episode 013 · 01:19:15. Field Edition · Play 01:19:15

gets, gets a lot of traction in the '80s, starts to replace the built-up roofs with the hot, hot buckets and hot mops. And then you have, uh, a movement into TPO that, you know, starts to work on some of that, uh, seam technology. It's white, it's reflective, and people love it, and, and it's really just running between EPDM and PVC, polyvinyl chloride, which is the, the roof assembly I believe is more of a premium product over TPO and has a lot of great things associated with it, including time and existence. TPO's still relatively new.

John Kiesel · Episode 013 · 01:19:22. Field Edition · Play 01:19:22

No speaker on Episode 013 stated a cost per square foot, or a service life in years, for TPO, EPDM, or PVC. The cost page records that gap. The lifespan page records the only year count John gives for a roof system that day, and it is coal tar pitch, not one of these three.

Questions this record can answer

Which membrane should I choose?

John Kiesel does not name one membrane for every roof. On Episode 013 he says TPO runs between EPDM and PVC, and he believes PVC is a more premium assembly than TPO, with more time in existence. He says TPO is still relatively new.

How do EPDM and TPO seams differ?

John Kiesel says an EPDM roof is a rubber roof with glued seams. He says those seams were failing because of the glue, and that TPO heat-welds the seam. He calls that seam change the reason TPO became popular. He also says TPO is white and reflective.

Were TPO, EPDM, and PVC proven when they arrived?

John Kiesel says TPO, PVC, and EPDM were experiments brought into the industry after hot tar roofs. He says TPO had a lot of failures when it was first rolled out, and that whole manufacturers are no longer in existence because it failed. He also says he thinks TPO is heading through its R&D phase.

Did anyone compare cost or years of life?

No guest on Episode 013 stated a price, or a service life in years, for TPO, EPDM, or PVC. See commercial roof cost per square foot and how long a commercial roof lasts. The year count John Kiesel does give that day is for a coal tar pitch built-up roof: 50 years.

Have a question for the show? Contact Roofing Authority Network.