Question of the Week · Week of November 18, 2026
Are Commercial Roof Coatings Worth It, and When Do They Fail?
Worth offering when there is still a membrane to preserve. On Episode 011, Steve Reiss of Division 7 Roofing says a coating is a membrane preservation system, and you have to know the right time. Restore a roof past that point and you have made a mess: the coating, then the full replacement. On Episode 013, John Kiesel says a coating is a fine enough product and has its applications. He would not rush to it being the savior.
A preservation system, and only while the roof can take it
On Episode 011, Keith Bilous puts the line as life left in the roof. In the next turn, Steve Reiss names what the coating is, and why the timing matters.
there has to be life left in the roof in order to restore it/coat it, because a lot of coatings, they're not, it's not necessarily a waterproofing system.
Keith Bilous · Episode 011 · 00:10:29. Field Edition · Play 00:10:29
It is a membrane preservation system, okay?
Steve Reiss · Episode 011 · 00:11:00. Field Edition · Play 00:11:00
it's important to be able to offer the service, but you have to know when is the right time
Steve Reiss · Episode 011 · 00:11:00. Field Edition · Play 00:11:00
Past that point, the bill stacks
Steve says the limit is structural stability. A restoration on a roof that is already past being restored does not hold, and the owner pays for the coating and then for the replacement.
It's more about the structural stability.
Steve Reiss · Episode 011 · 00:11:29. Field Edition · Play 00:11:29
if you try to restore a roof that's past the point of being restored
Steve Reiss · Episode 011 · 00:11:29. Field Edition · Play 00:11:29
you've made a mess
Steve Reiss · Episode 011 · 00:11:29. Field Edition · Play 00:11:29
you just paid, you know, 20% to 30% of a re-roof cost to restore it, and it doesn't work, so now you're going for the full replacement, so now you're looking at 130% of the cost
Steve Reiss · Episode 011 · 00:11:29. Field Edition · Play 00:11:29
One coated roof is not the proof
On Episode 013, John Kiesel of Division 7 Roofing answers a coating-company story about one data-center roof.
it's just simply riddled with, uh, coating propaganda
John Kiesel · Episode 013 · 00:11:26. Field Edition · Play 00:11:26
one roof that has an issue on a data center and a coating solution is driven to take care of it doesn't equate to being the best application
John Kiesel · Episode 013 · 00:11:26. Field Edition · Play 00:11:26
it certainly doesn't erode the, the PVC, uh, quality and performance
John Kiesel · Episode 013 · 00:11:26. Field Edition · Play 00:11:26
It could've been hit by hail
John Kiesel · Episode 013 · 00:11:26. Field Edition · Play 00:11:26
Coating is a fine enough product and certainly has its applications, but I wouldn't rush to it being the savior to PVC
John Kiesel · Episode 013 · 00:11:26. Field Edition · Play 00:11:26
Questions this record can answer
When is a commercial roof coating worth offering?
Steve Reiss says a coating is a membrane preservation system, and it is important to offer the service when you know the right time. Keith Bilous says there has to be life left in the roof to restore or coat it, because a lot of coatings are not necessarily a waterproofing system.
When does a coating fail the owner?
Steve Reiss says it is about structural stability. If you restore a roof past the point of being restored, you have made a mess. He says that can be 20% to 30% of a re-roof cost, and then the full replacement, which he puts at 130% of the cost the replacement would have taken.
Does one coated roof prove the product?
John Kiesel says a coating manufacturer's story about one data-center roof is coating propaganda. One roof with a coating solution is not the best application, and it does not erode PVC quality and performance. The roof could have been hit by hail. He says a coating is a fine enough product and has its applications, and he would not rush to it being the savior to PVC.
Did anyone compare silicone and acrylic coatings?
No guest or co-host on Episodes 011 or 013 named silicone or acrylic. Silicone appears only in a produced desk line on Episode 013, which this page does not quote. The on-air answer from Steve Reiss and John Kiesel is about coatings as restoration, and about when that restoration is past the point the roof can take.