Question of the Week · Week of November 11, 2026
How to Bid and Estimate a Commercial Roofing Job
Define the scope, price the risk in it, and follow up. On Episode 013, Dhaval Gajjar of Clemson University says a tighter scope means fewer surprises, because the work is about risk. On Episode 002, Holly Fuller of CBRE says a clear RFP gives everybody the same information so the numbers can be compared. On Episode 016, Jason Clayton of Carlisle Syntec Systems says sometimes the best jobs are the ones you do not get.
Define the scope tightly
On Episode 013, Dhaval Gajjar says scope definition is how you deal with risk before the project starts. Anything outside the scope is a conversation, not an assumption.
define your scope well, right? Don't leave anything for assumption. Don't leave anything for interpretation
Dhaval Gajjar · Episode 013 · 00:30:59. Field Edition · Play 00:30:59
the tighter the scope we have, the less surprises there is gonna be once you start the project, 'cause it's all about risk
Dhaval Gajjar · Episode 013 · 00:30:59. Field Edition · Play 00:30:59
Give every bidder the same information
On Episode 002, Holly Fuller says the property-manager side of a bid is a clear RFP. The same information is what makes the numbers comparable. Steve Reiss of Division 7 Roofing, in the same conversation, says an unclear scope does no one a favor.
how to write a good, like, RFP and scope, right? And be extremely clear and extremely forward and just, like, detailed on it, right? Of exactly what you're looking for, like, giving everybody all the same information
Holly Fuller · Episode 002 · 28:00. Field Edition · Play 28:00
that way you actually do get true numbers back. You're getting good things back that you can compare them, right?
Holly Fuller · Episode 002 · 28:00. Field Edition · Play 28:00
they just, like, blanketly throw something out there and say, "Give me a bid on this."
Holly Fuller · Episode 002 · 29:00. Field Edition · Play 29:00
how important it is to have clear apples to apples scopes.
Steve Reiss · Episode 002 · 29:00. Field Edition · Play 29:00
it doesn't do anyone a favor when we have unclear scopes of work.
Steve Reiss · Episode 002 · 30:00. Field Edition · Play 30:00
Price the risk, and know when to walk away
On Episode 016, Jason Clayton says the bid is a value that already includes the risk. Sometimes the best jobs are the ones you do not get, including when the other party cannot pay what the work is really going to cost.
Sometimes the best jobs are the jobs you don't get.
Jason Clayton · Episode 016 · 00:48:00. Field Edition · Play 00:48:00
let's evaluate the upside versus the risk
Jason Clayton · Episode 016 · 00:48:21. Field Edition · Play 00:48:21
putting a, a value, a proper value, uh, on the proposal that takes into account the risks
Jason Clayton · Episode 016 · 00:48:21. Field Edition · Play 00:48:21
maybe they can't afford to pay what it really is gonna cost
Jason Clayton · Episode 016 · 00:49:21. Field Edition · Play 00:49:21
Follow up on every estimate
On Episode 017, Mike Stiers of Greenbaum Stiers says a low bid rate has to be diagnosed, and that not following up on estimates hurts what comes after.
we have visibility to the fact that there's a low bid rate, we wanna identify, is this just a, a poor opportunity, you know, a poorly qualified opportunity
Mike Stiers · Episode 017 · 00:30:48. Field Edition · Play 00:30:48
not following up with estimates, because it does hurt downstream
Mike Stiers · Episode 017 · 00:30:48. Field Edition · Play 00:30:48
A repair needs an estimate too
On The Service Side, Episode 01, Reed Dietz of Roof Revivers says the repair is a diagnosis and a price, not only a tear-off. Roof Revivers presents that show. People who want the work done go to Roof Revivers in Columbus.
they just don't know how to diagnose the repair, figure out what's wrong, and how to price the repair
Reed Dietz · The Service Side 001 · 2:06. Episode 01 · Play 2:06
We're the only ones that ever actually provide an estimate.
Reed Dietz · The Service Side 001 · 14:06. Episode 01 · Play 14:06
Questions this record can answer
What should a commercial roofing bid start with?
Dhaval Gajjar says to define the scope well and leave nothing for assumption or interpretation. A tighter scope means fewer surprises, because the work is about risk.
What does a property manager need in order to compare bids?
Holly Fuller says a clear RFP and scope gives everybody the same information, so the numbers that come back can be compared. A blanket request skips the other items a real scope has to cover. Steve Reiss says unclear scopes of work do no one a favor.
When should the contractor walk away?
Jason Clayton says sometimes the best jobs are the jobs you don't get. He says to evaluate the upside versus the risk and put a proper value on the proposal that takes the risks into account. Sometimes the other party cannot afford what the work is really going to cost.
Does a repair need an estimate too?
Reed Dietz says many roofers do not know how to diagnose a repair, figure out what is wrong, and price it. He says his company is the one that actually provides an estimate.